Insights
Green check mark burst shape
Premium

Good Enough, for Now—a Lesson from My Own Book Proposals

Your book proposal doesn’t have to be perfect—but it should have these eight elements.

9
minute read
Published on
April 7, 2025
In a few years, when you look back on what you’re writing today, you might be embarrassed by the quality of your work or your writing choices. But that’s actually a good thing.

I recently reviewed the proposals I wrote when selling three of my (nine) books—Book Yourself Solid, The Contrarian Effect, and Steal the Show. 

As I read through the earliest one, for Book Yourself Solid—which I wrote in 2005—and then the one for The Contrarian Effect, which I wrote a few years later in 2008, I felt like I wanted to throw up.

Seriously.

I cringed at some of my writing. I hated certain choices I made. I questioned my approach in entire sections. 

But here’s the thing: all of those books sold. All of those books became hits. And two of them even became really big hits, making it onto major bestseller lists.

So if those proposals—written by a much less experienced version of me—were good enough to sell, and if those books were good enough to succeed, what does that tell you about your own work right now?

Full Transcript

Read Full Transcript
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
Black right arrow icon
To build a body of work that matters, focus on making it the best you can—today.

Looking Back at Your Work Can Be Painful (and That’s a Good Thing)

In 20 years, when you look back at what you’re writing today, you might feel the same way I did when reading my old book proposals—embarrassed by some of your choices, some of your writing, some of your techniques.

But that’s a good thing.

It means you’ve grown. It means you’re better now than you used to be. It means your craft has evolved. 

It means you’re much closer today to achieving mastery than you were all those years ago. And that’s exactly what building a legacy is all about—taking the next best step, iterating consistently, being patient with yourself, and trusting the process.

X Mark icon
Don't
worry about whether or not what you’re creating right now is worthy of lasting forever.
Check mark icon
Do
make sure it’s good enough—then keep going. Keep growing. Keep improving. Keep writing. Keep performing.

The truth is not everyone is going to write like AJ Harper, multi-award-winning author and ghostwriter and editor for some of today’s most elite thought leaders. She’s an author who—let’s face it—writes at a level most people will never reach. 

But you don’t have to write like AJ to build a valuable body of work that serves your audience. Your work just needs to be good enough.

You see, not everything you create needs to be remarkable. Of course, you should always strive to provide value to your readers and deliver high-quality content. But if you try to make everything a masterpiece, you’ll never finish anything. You won’t be able to deliver.

So don’t get caught up in perfection. Just make sure it’s good enough and keep going.

The Eight Essential Elements of an Effective Book Proposal 

Like AJ Harper says, a book proposal is simply a business plan for your book. In it, you’ll outline who your book serves, why you’re offering it right now, and how you’ll market and promote it. Building a book proposal can help you gain clarity for both writing and promoting your book, understand your market, and help you refine your outline. 

Depending on the publishing path you choose, you might not need a book proposal—but creating one can give you a valuable guide that can help you position your book for success. 

Each of my—now cringe-worthy—book proposals was good enough, and propelled me forward to more creative work (and yes, more books—probably a few too many). And each of my book proposals had the essentials to make them work. You see, to craft a winning book proposal, make sure you include these eight things: 

The Overview 

Perhaps the most challenging and important part of your proposal is the overview. Here, you want to hook the editors, publishers, and agents reading your proposal right out of the gate by showing them your book’s primary reader, powerful promise, and core message. Describe the problem your book will solve and why the world needs your book, right now. 

Excellent book proposals capture attention from the very first page. It takes time to write and refine an enticing overview, so be patient with yourself and the process. And remember, when it’s good enough, move on. 

In GRAD | Book Writing Mastery, you’ll find the eight questions your book-proposal overview must answer to pique a publisher’s interest and compel them to read your proposal. Talk to an advisor about the upcoming cohort here

Your Target Audience

When you describe your target market in your book proposal, you’ll want to include basic information and statistics about size, along with the psychographics—for each segment of your target audience. 

Just like knowing your audience is essential for crafting a transformational speech, knowing your readers is crucial for writing a meaningful book. AJ Harper always reminds thought leaders: “A book is not about something—a book is for someone.” That’s the core message of her award-winning book, Write a Must-Read: How to Craft a Book That Changes Lives—Including Your Own—and it’s something every aspiring author should keep front of mind. 

About the Author

In this section, your goal is to position yourself as an authority. What qualifications and experiences make you the best person to write about this topic and present your solution to the problem? 

Make sure your biography is relevant to your book’s topic and core message. For example, in my book proposal for The Contrarian Effect, I focused on my journey in sales—and how my background in acting helped me be fully self-expressed and fully transparent. I didn’t follow traditional sales advice—in fact, I focused on doing the exact opposite, which is exactly what the book is about. 

A Competitive Title Analysis

In this section, you’ll want to mention three to seven books that are competitive with yours. Describe how each book serves its readers and what it accomplishes, and explain how yours is different. 

Make sure the books you choose are recent publications—preferably within the last two years—and are selling well. You don’t have to compare your book to award-winning bestsellers that have sold millions of copies. In fact, AJ Harper recommends you don’t. Most publishers realize that results like that are unusual, and if they see it in your book proposal, they usually won’t consider it a viable comparison. 

 

Your Marketing and Promotion Plan 

Here, you’ll describe your plan for getting your book into your readers’ hands. It’s a good idea to include the size of your following, mailing lists, and connections. Include a list of people and organizations who will help you market your book, along with the approximate number of people they can reach. 

In my book proposal for Steal the Show, for example, I outlined my plan to deliver keynote speeches, make guest appearances on TV, produce webinars, write blog posts, fund and host a launch party, utilize social media, and maximize valuable connections to ensure the book’s launch, marketing, and promotion were successful. 

In GRAD | Speaking Business Mastery, students finish the program with a full publishing plan to get their book into readers’ hands—in a way that aligns with their goals and resources. When you have a publishing plan, you can include parts of your plan in this section of your book proposal. 

Outline & Chapter Descriptions

An effective book proposal includes the table of contents for your book, along with a detailed description for each chapter. In your chapter descriptions, include unique and exclusive stories, frameworks, research, and case studies. 

To help you craft strong chapter descriptions, ask yourself: 

  • What is the main takeaway from this chapter? 
  • How does the content in this chapter get my reader closer to the book’s promise? 
  • Why is this chapter absolutely essential for the reader? 

Manuscript Specifications 

Make sure to include in your book proposal how many words you expect your book to be, and an approximate date for the completion of your manuscript. This is also the place to mention if you have any unique design elements, photos, or specifications for your book. 

My book The Contrarian Effect was originally titled The Costanza Principle, a reference to George Costanza from Seinfeld, who started doing the opposite of everything he normally would do—with spectacular results. 

And in the book proposal, I specified that I wanted the cover to look and feel like velvet—since George Costanza dreamed of being draped in velvet. That request didn’t play out in the end, and we ended up changing the title of the book (although, I really never should have changed this title—but that’s a story for another day). 

Sample Chapters (Including Chapter 1) 

When deciding which chapters to include in your book proposal, make sure you include Chapter 1. Your book’s opening chapter should connect deeply with readers and propel them to keep reading. 

The agents, publishers, and editors will read your sample chapters to get a feel for your writing style and analyze how you present your content. That being said, don’t overthink it. Choose your strongest or favorite chapters—the ones you’re most excited to show the world—and remember, good enough is good enough. 

X Mark icon
Don't
expect your book proposal to be perfect.
Check mark icon
Do
start crafting a book proposal that’s good enough for now.

When you know your primary reader, your core message, and your promise, you have enough to start writing your book proposal. Building your book proposal before finishing your first draft can help you get valuable feedback from editors, publishers, and agents and set your book up for success.

   

Whatever You’re Producing Now, It’s the Best You Can Do—For Now.

When you consistently make sure your current work is good enough—then keep going—you’ll discover that your “good enough” is slowly becoming something remarkable. 

Because here’s the magic: each time you do that next thing, it will be better than the one before. The book proposal for Steal the Show was better than the one for Book Yourself Solid, because I wrote it almost ten years later, with ten years more of experience. And the book proposals I wrote after Book Yourself Solid were even better. 

It’s not about perfection. It’s about progress. 

That’s how you grow. That’s how you improve. That’s how you build a body of work that matters.

So stop worrying about creating the next timeless masterpiece. Just focus on getting it done and making it the best you can—today.

Years from now, you’ll look back and realize that what you thought was only “good enough” was actually the foundation of something great.

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do

|

Community. Accountability. Commitment.

GRAD

|

Book Writing Mastery

Get the complete Book Proposal Template—along with the essential and repeatable book-writing fundamentals you need to draft, edit, pitch, and publish your book successfully.
Talk to an Advisor Today

First Name
First Name
Last Name
Last Name
Email address
Email address
Who referred you?
First & Last Name
Checkmark icon
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Looking Back at Your Work Can Be Painful (and That’s a Good Thing)

In 20 years, when you look back at what you’re writing today, you might feel the same way I did when reading my old book proposals—embarrassed by some of your choices, some of your writing, some of your techniques.

But that’s a good thing.

It means you’ve grown. It means you’re better now than you used to be. It means your craft has evolved. 

It means you’re much closer today to achieving mastery than you were all those years ago. And that’s exactly what building a legacy is all about—taking the next best step, iterating consistently, being patient with yourself, and trusting the process.

X Mark icon
Dont
worry about whether or not what you’re creating right now is worthy of lasting forever.
Check mark icon
Do
make sure it’s good enough—then keep going. Keep growing. Keep improving. Keep writing. Keep performing.
To build a body of work that matters, focus on making it the best you can—today.

The truth is not everyone is going to write like AJ Harper, multi-award-winning author and ghostwriter and editor for some of today’s most elite thought leaders. She’s an author who—let’s face it—writes at a level most people will never reach. 

But you don’t have to write like AJ to build a valuable body of work that serves your audience. Your work just needs to be good enough.

You see, not everything you create needs to be remarkable. Of course, you should always strive to provide value to your readers and deliver high-quality content. But if you try to make everything a masterpiece, you’ll never finish anything. You won’t be able to deliver.

So don’t get caught up in perfection. Just make sure it’s good enough and keep going.

The Eight Essential Elements of an Effective Book Proposal 

Like AJ Harper says, a book proposal is simply a business plan for your book. In it, you’ll outline who your book serves, why you’re offering it right now, and how you’ll market and promote it. Building a book proposal can help you gain clarity for both writing and promoting your book, understand your market, and help you refine your outline. 

Depending on the publishing path you choose, you might not need a book proposal—but creating one can give you a valuable guide that can help you position your book for success. 

Each of my—now cringe-worthy—book proposals was good enough, and propelled me forward to more creative work (and yes, more books—probably a few too many). And each of my book proposals had the essentials to make them work. You see, to craft a winning book proposal, make sure you include these eight things: 

The Overview 

Perhaps the most challenging and important part of your proposal is the overview. Here, you want to hook the editors, publishers, and agents reading your proposal right out of the gate by showing them your book’s primary reader, powerful promise, and core message. Describe the problem your book will solve and why the world needs your book, right now. 

Excellent book proposals capture attention from the very first page. It takes time to write and refine an enticing overview, so be patient with yourself and the process. And remember, when it’s good enough, move on. 

In GRAD | Book Writing Mastery, you’ll find the eight questions your book-proposal overview must answer to pique a publisher’s interest and compel them to read your proposal. Talk to an advisor about the upcoming cohort here

Your Target Audience

When you describe your target market in your book proposal, you’ll want to include basic information and statistics about size, along with the psychographics—for each segment of your target audience. 

Just like knowing your audience is essential for crafting a transformational speech, knowing your readers is crucial for writing a meaningful book. AJ Harper always reminds thought leaders: “A book is not about something—a book is for someone.” That’s the core message of her award-winning book, Write a Must-Read: How to Craft a Book That Changes Lives—Including Your Own—and it’s something every aspiring author should keep front of mind. 

About the Author

In this section, your goal is to position yourself as an authority. What qualifications and experiences make you the best person to write about this topic and present your solution to the problem? 

Make sure your biography is relevant to your book’s topic and core message. For example, in my book proposal for The Contrarian Effect, I focused on my journey in sales—and how my background in acting helped me be fully self-expressed and fully transparent. I didn’t follow traditional sales advice—in fact, I focused on doing the exact opposite, which is exactly what the book is about. 

A Competitive Title Analysis

In this section, you’ll want to mention three to seven books that are competitive with yours. Describe how each book serves its readers and what it accomplishes, and explain how yours is different. 

Make sure the books you choose are recent publications—preferably within the last two years—and are selling well. You don’t have to compare your book to award-winning bestsellers that have sold millions of copies. In fact, AJ Harper recommends you don’t. Most publishers realize that results like that are unusual, and if they see it in your book proposal, they usually won’t consider it a viable comparison. 

 

Your Marketing and Promotion Plan 

Here, you’ll describe your plan for getting your book into your readers’ hands. It’s a good idea to include the size of your following, mailing lists, and connections. Include a list of people and organizations who will help you market your book, along with the approximate number of people they can reach. 

In my book proposal for Steal the Show, for example, I outlined my plan to deliver keynote speeches, make guest appearances on TV, produce webinars, write blog posts, fund and host a launch party, utilize social media, and maximize valuable connections to ensure the book’s launch, marketing, and promotion were successful. 

In GRAD | Speaking Business Mastery, students finish the program with a full publishing plan to get their book into readers’ hands—in a way that aligns with their goals and resources. When you have a publishing plan, you can include parts of your plan in this section of your book proposal. 

Outline & Chapter Descriptions

An effective book proposal includes the table of contents for your book, along with a detailed description for each chapter. In your chapter descriptions, include unique and exclusive stories, frameworks, research, and case studies. 

To help you craft strong chapter descriptions, ask yourself: 

  • What is the main takeaway from this chapter? 
  • How does the content in this chapter get my reader closer to the book’s promise? 
  • Why is this chapter absolutely essential for the reader? 

Manuscript Specifications 

Make sure to include in your book proposal how many words you expect your book to be, and an approximate date for the completion of your manuscript. This is also the place to mention if you have any unique design elements, photos, or specifications for your book. 

My book The Contrarian Effect was originally titled The Costanza Principle, a reference to George Costanza from Seinfeld, who started doing the opposite of everything he normally would do—with spectacular results. 

And in the book proposal, I specified that I wanted the cover to look and feel like velvet—since George Costanza dreamed of being draped in velvet. That request didn’t play out in the end, and we ended up changing the title of the book (although, I really never should have changed this title—but that’s a story for another day). 

Sample Chapters (Including Chapter 1) 

When deciding which chapters to include in your book proposal, make sure you include Chapter 1. Your book’s opening chapter should connect deeply with readers and propel them to keep reading. 

The agents, publishers, and editors will read your sample chapters to get a feel for your writing style and analyze how you present your content. That being said, don’t overthink it. Choose your strongest or favorite chapters—the ones you’re most excited to show the world—and remember, good enough is good enough. 

X Mark icon
Don't
expect your book proposal to be perfect.
Check mark icon
Do
start crafting a book proposal that’s good enough for now.
,

When you know your primary reader, your core message, and your promise, you have enough to start writing your book proposal. Building your book proposal before finishing your first draft can help you get valuable feedback from editors, publishers, and agents and set your book up for success.

   

Whatever You’re Producing Now, It’s the Best You Can Do—For Now.

When you consistently make sure your current work is good enough—then keep going—you’ll discover that your “good enough” is slowly becoming something remarkable. 

Because here’s the magic: each time you do that next thing, it will be better than the one before. The book proposal for Steal the Show was better than the one for Book Yourself Solid, because I wrote it almost ten years later, with ten years more of experience. And the book proposals I wrote after Book Yourself Solid were even better. 

It’s not about perfection. It’s about progress. 

That’s how you grow. That’s how you improve. That’s how you build a body of work that matters.

So stop worrying about creating the next timeless masterpiece. Just focus on getting it done and making it the best you can—today.

Years from now, you’ll look back and realize that what you thought was only “good enough” was actually the foundation of something great.

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
Education graduation cap black icon
Learn from
Michael

HEROIC

Speakers

Learn how to give speeches that transform how people think and perceive the world. We’ll teach you how to write, perform, and get booked.
Learn more
X Mark icon
Dont
Check mark icon
Do
white space
Loading
Someone is typing...
Person icon
No Name
Set
Moderator
(Edited)
4 years ago
This is the actual comment. It's can be long or short. And must contain only text information.
Person profile icon with blue background
No Name
Set
2 years ago
Moderator
(Edited)
This is the actual comment. It's can be long or short. And must contain only text information.
Load More
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Load More
white space